My fellow Americans, your silence is deafening
search
OpinionGuest Columnist

My fellow Americans, your silence is deafening

Allegedly “woke” progressives jump on the anti-Israel bandwagon

Protestors gathered in Oakland with signs protesting Israel and its response to the current Palestinian conflict. Brian Burke believes America needs to stand in solidarity with Israel. Photo by David Rullo.
Protestors gathered in Oakland with signs protesting Israel and its response to the current Palestinian conflict. Brian Burke believes America needs to stand in solidarity with Israel. Photo by David Rullo.

During a time of growing anti-Asian hate, civil society organizations, businesses, political leaders and individuals have rallied against this evil phenomena and in support of the Asian American and Pacific Islander community.

As LGBTQ rights come under attack in state legislatures and individuals continue to face discrimination because of who they love or how they define themselves, people of good conscience have pushed back to fight homophobia and transphobia.

Sadly, this activism seems to end when Jews are the target of the hatred.

The Jewish experience in America is unique in Jewish history. Jews have had periods of relative safety and prosperity in other diaspora communities over the past 3000 years, but nothing compares to the overall feelings of safety and comfort the overwhelming majority of Americans Jews have felt.

Yes, we have faced the oldest hatred even in the country that has by and large been a pretty good place to be a Jew. From quotas in school admissions to employment discrimination, the inability to join certain social clubs or being scapegoated for the economic ills of the day, Jews have not been immune from hatred since the earliest communities were established in the 13 colonies.

Antisemitism has manifested itself in physical attacks on Jews, synagogues and Jewish institutions. Nevertheless, antisemitism in the United States has not been systemic, widespread, or, at its most evil, genocidal in the same manner as it has been across Europe and the Middle East.

Yet, let me be abundantly clear: Jews have largely not experienced discrimination and racism in the same ways as some other minority groups in this country. (There are Jews of all races and ethnicities. I am only talking about the community as a whole, not the experiences of individual Jews).

We were not enslaved, subject to segregation and Jim Crow laws, and still having to face systemic racism in the criminal justice system and across other parts of American society and culture.

We were not the victims of deadly attacks by U.S. troops and forced onto reservations in drastically smaller numbers compared to the years prior to European colonization and westward American expansion, and still dealing with the consequences of those events and decades of social and economic neglect.

We were not forced into internment camps simply because of our ancestry, fetishized or blamed for a deadly pandemic.

However, that does not matter. I have no interest in feeding into pointless arguments about “oppression olympics.” No, American Jews have not, generally speaking as a community, faced the same challenges and hardships as African Americans, Native Americans or Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders. So what? Why does that matter when we are under attack on streets across this country?

Solidarity after the horrific events of Oct. 27, 2018, was and continues to be greatly appreciated. It was easy to stand with us after the worst antisemitic attack in American history. I guess it’s a lot harder now when we are “just” beaten and harassed during times of active conflict in Israel. These recent spates of attacks and incidents are based on countless antisemitic tropes. Targeting Jews because of anger about what is going on in Israel is antisemitism. Calling Jews who support Israel Nazis, or claiming Zionism is Nazism, is antisemitic. Saying Jews killed Jesus is antisemitic. The list goes on.

Today’s antisemitic hate does not just come from far-right white supremacists. Allegedly “woke” progressives jump on the anti-Israel bandwagon, project American concepts of race and power onto a geopolitical conflict halfway across the world they know nothing about, and deny Israel’s right to exist. Thugs draped in Palestinian flags and keffiyehs yell hateful slurs and attack Jews walking in Manhattan and eating sushi in southern California.

Condemnation and calls for action by the president, vice president and leading figures in Congress are welcome steps, but nearly everyone else is MIA. Where are all of the social justice warriors? Why isn’t fighting antisemitism part and parcel of contemporary activism, alongside efforts to dismantle systemic racism, push back against despicable attacks on Asian Americans and countless other issues?

My fellow Americans, we Jews see and hear you loud and clear. Your silence is deafening. PJC

Brian Burke is a Pittsburgh native and 2019 graduate of the University of Pittsburgh, where he studied political science, history and Jewish studies. In college, he was involved with Hillel and the David Project, holding several leadership positions including president of the Pitt Hillel Jewish Student Union in 2018.

read more:
comments