JCPA: Community Relations are in crisis

An increase in anti-Semitism, an intensification of anti-Israel activity and decades of neglect have created a crisis in the Jewish community relations field, according to the umbrella group for Jewish public policy organizations, the Jewish Council for Public Affairs.

In reports published this week at its annual Washington meeting, the group urged a radical shift among its constituent Jewish community relations councils, which advocate for Jewish issues on behalf of the Jewish community at the local level.

The shift would mean engaging with other ethnic and civic groups and more assertively including Jewish voices in broader conversations about bias, Israel and a range of other issues where Jewish communities have led in the past.

Get The Jewish Chronicle Weekly Edition by email and never miss our top stories Free Sign Up

The JCPA wants constituents to contribute toward nearly doubling its existing budget with hopes of training a new cadre of Jewish outreach officials across the country.

“The Jewish community does not have the network of relationships it did with other communities and leaders it did 30 or 40 years ago,” said David Brown, the co-chairman of a JCPA task force that spent a year presenting the report. “We absolutely need them.”

Brown also referred to reports of a rise in anti-Semitic attacks and an increase in anti-Israel activity on campuses.

“It’s become politically OK to say things that were certainly amped down for a generation or two,” he said.

The four-day annual conference, which ran from Feb. 8-11, drew some 250 professionals and volunteers. The sessions reflected the range of policy issues being dealt with at the local level by CRCs, including criminal justice reform, immigration, #MeToo, the social safety net and BDS.

The report undergirding Brown’s remarks, and a panel after he delivered them, painted a dire picture of the decline of the prominence of the Jewish voice in such issues. It blamed a number of factors, including the widening divide between Israel and the Diaspora, the disenchantment of millennials with the norms of their elders, and the difficulties inherent in an essentially liberal U.S. Jewish community grappling with the emergence of anti-Semitism on the left as well as the right.

The reports identified the decline of the Jewish community relations council. Such councils flourished in the years following World War II, when American Jewish leaders sought to include Jews in the framing of public policy. Its success was seen in the preeminence of Jews in the civil rights movement, the proliferation of Jewish lawmakers and the fact that Americans remain overwhelmingly pro-Israel.

That success didn’t last, said one of the several reports released at the conference: “Following the Oslo Process and the resolution of the plight of Soviet Jewry, areas of the community relations field experienced a decline. The U.S. Jewish community shifted its focus to internal challenges of Jewish education and identity with the belief that peace could be achieved, anti-Semitism was declining, and oppressed Jewish communities were now free.”

These and other trends “are limiting the effectiveness of community relations organizations and initiatives.” While CRCs in major cities are robust, JCPA officials said, among the 125 affiliated with the umbrella, many are staffed by one person or manned by volunteers.

That creates a vacuum, said Gidi Grinstein, the founder of Reut, an Israeli think-tank that issued one of the reports. When crises demand responses, Jewish voices are lacking.

“This country is so big, the communities are so diverse, the issues are so different, the only way to contain what we’re talking about here” — the rise of anti-Semitism and of anti-Israel activism — “is a network of local organizations that have the talent, the methodology and the technology,” Grinstein said.

At the annual meeting, and at a board meeting last month, the JCPA lay and professional leadership launched a pitch based on the Reut report to donors and constituent community relations councils to raise $1.6 million — almost doubling its existing $1.8 million budget — to hire officials to make up for the gap. Part of the plan would be to make the larger and more robust councils hubs that would assist the smaller ones in their regions.

At the conference, JCPA officials acknowledged two additional obstacles to reviving a robust Jewish presence in community affairs: an Israeli government that has trended rightward, and with its actions has alienated liberals, and the disruptive politics of the moment.

There was much talk at the conference of the need to broaden the capacity for criticism of Israel while continuing to delegitimize calls to bring an end to Israel as a Jewish state.

“Let’s be honest that when acting as advocates to engage liberals with Israel, the current government’s policies can make for a really bad client,” Jeremy Burton, the executive director of Boston’s JCRC, said during a panel. “Which requires moral clarity about our absolutes like delegitimization of Israel’s existence and nuance about criticism.”

Melanie Gorelick, JCPA’s senior vice president, said the JCPA would have to make the case to the disaffected that the best arena to advance favored policies, in a Jewish setting, was the local JCRC.

“We are the only organizations that come together and tackle day-to-day issues” with the right and the left at the table, she said. pjc