Letters to the editor
OpinionFeedback

Letters to the editor

Readers respond

(Photo from Flash90)
(Photo from Flash90)

A troubling political divide
While perusing the Nov. 13 edition of the Chronicle, I noted some of the headlines about the midterms and how the state of present-day politics affects American Jewry: “‘It’s Complicated’: Jewish voters react to midterm election results”; “Gaza-born anti-Israel writer challenges Fetterman in 2028 primary”; “Democratic Socialists push for anti-Israel boycott in Oakland”; “Democracy was top Jewish concern in midterms, not Israel or antisemitism.”

Then, on page 13, there’s a graph showing that a 56% majority of Jewish voters responding to a Chronicle poll question were not pleased with the results of the election. Reading through the comments, not one had a single positive thing to say about the Trump administration. I assume that the comments the Chronicle chose to print were representative. If so, I see an irrevocable rift among us Jews — those who see Trump positively and as the most pro-Israel president, and those who, in their own words, accuse him (without citing a single example) of having “brought chaos, coarseness, bigotry and incompetence upon the country.”

I have to remind people who think like that, that it was Trump who moved the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, who fostered the Abraham Accords and who supported Israel militarily in defeating Iran’s nuclear threat. I have to remind people who think like that, that the Abdul Al-Sayeds and Summer Lees are the real existential dangers, not only for Israel but also for American Jews. The present Democratic Party, which would seek to unseat a John Fetterman, is not the party I want in power.

While I am certainly aware of the anti-Israel and outright antisemitism on the right, I also see many prominent Republicans — Rubio, De Santis, Huckabee and Cruz, for example — fighting that wing. I see almost none on the left, including the shameful Chuck Schumer, who has the chutzpah to call himself Israel’s protector. Israel is supported by over 80% of Trump supporters and only 30% or so by the Democrats.

So, in reply to anyone who believes that the election was in any way “great for the country,” I say you are not only wrong but delusionary. Any election that is bad for Israel also bodes poorly for the United States, and particularly its Jewish population.

Robert Ennis
Pittsburgh

Let the justice system run its course
Regarding Carl Fertman’s op-ed “A Jew sitting in two rooms” (Nov. 13): I truly hope that Mr. Fertman and his referenced fellow congregants will someday come to peace with our justice system.

When he writes of the community suffering from the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter’s ongoing legal proceedings, I am thrown back to eight years ago, when so many were calling for prosecutors to sweep the matter under the rug, avoid a trial and throw the criminal in jail for life, lest we all suffer more. At the time, those of us who witnessed the crime — many of whom disagreed with those folks — were advised not to speak publicly about details, the criminal, or sentencing, but their predicted suffering was widely reported.

The prosecution chose to try the criminal to the full extent of the law, and the breadth and detail of the evidence collected by the prosecution team was not torture to many of those hearing it; it was enlightening. Without the trial we would not have known the extent of the criminal’s hatred, how he hunted and dispatched each victim, how he appreciates “room and board” in prison, how facile he is with computers, or how much he likes publicity and idolizing acolytes. We might not have learned that a life sentence offers television and goldfish in one’s cell, as well as regular social engagement and increasing computer use.

Based on the evidence, I think he deserves to be right where he is now, on death row, cut off from others, with limited computer access and limited interactions. The purpose of a death sentence (not a “death penalty,” as we don’t punish by death) is to cut off the perpetrator from society, never to commit the crime again, nor influence others to do so. When we find the appropriate law to accomplish that without having to sentence a criminal to death, then we can delete “death” from the list of sentences. Until that time, this remains the best tool to keep this brand of perpetrator away from society.

I am tired of reading about our community suffering — because so many of us are not, and refuse to let the criminal harm us further.

I attended the hearing, and though I would never discount others’ emotions and it wasn’t a romp in the park, I did not feel “disconnected, isolated, and scared.” I care about the case, the U.S. attorneys who are prosecuting it, and the outcome. And I hope the murderer remains right where he is for the rest of his natural life.

Audrey Glickman
Pittsburgh

read more:
comments