Scapegoating Israel for Trump’s personal flaws
A new relationship with Israel may emerge, but that is not the reason Republicans lost.

Vice President JD Vance wasted no time blaming “our relationship with Israel” for Republican losses in the midterm elections. It seems like Vance intends to argue in his 2028 bid for president that he opposed the war against Iran and that President Trump was talked into the war by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Vance’s account is wrong on two levels. First, the midterm results were about domestic grievances, not directly about foreign policy. Voters objected to many administration policies, including those supported enthusiastically by Vance. Second, Trump was not talked into the war.
The war came about because of his personal combination of insecurity and arrogance and his incompetent style of government.
Get The Jewish Chronicle Weekly Edition by email and never miss our top stories Free Sign Up
In political terms, it may well be true that the American people want a changed relationship with Israel. Both among Republicans and Democrats there is much more criticism of Israel’s conduct in Gaza and on the West Bank.
You can reject the false charge of genocide against Israel while still suspecting the Israeli government of creating conditions that it hopes will lead Palestinians to go somewhere else.
But there is no reason to believe that growing empathy for the Palestinian people had anything to do with the midterm results. A new relationship with Israel may emerge, but that is not the reason Republicans lost.
There were a lot of reasons voters soured on Trump other than foreign affairs. It is true that voters were unhappy with high prices caused in part by the Iranian war. But a confused and haphazard tariff regime also raised prices and, crucially, cut off American farmers from important agricultural markets. Mass deportations of law-abiding people without documentation surprised and angered Hispanic voters and hurt the economy. The military occupation of the District of Columbia upset Black voters, as did Republican efforts across the country to eliminate Black representation in Congress. In addition, Trump’s personal style, dictatorial and weirdly detached from the problems of ordinary people, magnified his policy failures.
The war against Iran is unpopular because it dragged on despite Trump’s promises of an early and easy resolution, not because they thought Trump was acting on behalf of Israel. Trump was not pursuing a novel policy in trying to curb Iran. The whole world has opposed Iranian nuclear ambitions, including Europe, China and Russia. America has engaged Iran and its proxies militarily on numerous occasions since Ronald Reagan’s naval campaign in 1988. Public reaction to Trump’s bombing of Iran’s nuclear facilities in June 2025 was mixed, but certainly his action was not universally unpopular. And no one thought that bombing was motivated solely by Trump’s support of Israel. American opposition to Iran’s nuclear efforts are longstanding.
The Republican problem regarding the war Trump started in February 2026 was that Trump had unrealistic expectations. He did not win an easy victory and now there is no obvious way out of a stalemate that not only raised the price of oil but may have handed Iran permanent control of the Strait of Hormuz — a disastrous result. Reports indicate that Trump was unprepared for the closure of the strait and did not appreciate the practical limits of the effectiveness of an air campaign. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and others failed to prepare the president adequately.
With regard to Netanyahu’s role in starting the war, the scapegoating of Israel is a false narrative. Certainly Netanyahu urged Trump to join with Israel in attacking Iran and that turned out to be bad advice. But Trump has never been Netanyahu’s puppet. In October 2025, Trump essentially imposed a ceasefire in Gaza on Israel despite Netanyahu’s obvious reluctance. Trump makes his own decisions.
Trump’s reasons for attacking Iran are unclear, but in my view they had more to do with his obsession with President Obama than with concerns about Israel. There was a moment following the June 2025 bombing of Iran’s nuclear facilities when Iran and the U.S. were close to a deal — certainly a much better deal than Trump can get now. If Trump had agreed to a deal then, there would have been no war, no higher gas prices, no closure of the strait, and, politically, smaller losses in the midterms.
But any deal in 2025 would not have been materially different from the one Obama negotiated with Iran in 2015. Not only would accepting such an outcome have diminished Trump’s need to show himself to be superior to Obama, it would also have suggested that Trump’s abrogation of that Iranian agreement in 2017 was a costly and needless mistake. Trump is not a man who can easily admit making a mistake.
To better Obama, Trump needed a bigger triumph over Iran. He needed regime change in Tehran. That is the reason Trump heeded Netanyahu’s siren call for war. Trump’s combination of insecurity and arrogance, coupled with the poor policy advice he gets from the incompetent people he surrounds himself with, explain the Iranian debacle. Trump’s poor character led America into an unpopular war. It was not some extreme devotion to the interests of Israel.
Scapegoating Israel for all this is just another way for those people who supported Trump’s election in 2024, despite his known weaknesses, to avoid taking responsibility for their misjudgment. That includes Vance, who, despite all his overwhelming ambition, is now not likely to be the Republican nominee for president in 2028. PJC
Bruce Ledewitz is professor of law emeritus at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. The views expressed in this article do not reflect those of Duquesne University.
comments